Current:Home > NewsJudge rejects dismissal, rules Prince Harry’s lawsuit against Daily Mail can go to trial -WealthStream
Judge rejects dismissal, rules Prince Harry’s lawsuit against Daily Mail can go to trial
View
Date:2025-04-27 22:01:01
LONDON — A lawsuit by Prince Harry, Elton John and five other public figures accusing a newspaper publisher of using private detectives and listening devices to illegally snoop on them should go to a full trial, a British judge ruled Friday.
Judge Matthew Nicklin rejected a bid by the publisher of the Daily Mail to dismiss the case without trial, saying defense lawyers had not delivered a "knockout blow" to the claims.
The claimants, who include John’s husband David Furnish and actors Elizabeth Hurley and Sadie Frost, accuse publisher Associated Newspapers Ltd. of unlawfully gathering information by bugging homes and cars, recording phone conversations and using deceit to obtain medical records.
Harry said the publisher targeted him and the people closest to him by unlawfully hacking voicemails, tapping landlines, obtaining itemized phone bills and the flight information of his then-girlfriend, Chelsy Davy.
Associated Newspapers strongly denies the allegations and asked the judge to throw out the case. At hearings in March, its lawyers argued that the claims – which date as far back as 1993 – were brought too late and that claimants were relying on confidential evidence the papers turned over to a 2012 public inquiry into tabloid wrongdoing, sparked by revelations of phone hacking by the now-defunct News of the World.
Nicklin ruled that the claimants cannot rely on the documents handed over to the inquiry, which were ordered to be kept confidential by its head, Brian Leveson. They allegedly include records of payments to private investigators by the Daily Mail and the Mail on Sunday.
Prince Harry's lawsuits,from phone hacking to aerial photos: What to know
But the judge said the case can go ahead because the claims "have a real prospect of succeeding."
"Associated has not been able to deliver a ‘knockout blow’ to the claims of any of these claimants," the judge said in a written ruling.
He rejected the publisher’s argument that the case should be dismissed because the claims had not been brought within six years of the alleged offense.
"In my judgment, each claimant has a real prospect of demonstrating that Associated, or those for whom Associated is responsible, concealed from him/her the relevant facts upon which a worthwhile claim of unlawful information gathering could have been advanced," the judge wrote.
The seven claimants, who also include anti-racism campaigner Doreen Lawrence and former politician Simon Hughes, said they were "delighted" by the judgment.
"As we have maintained since the outset, we bring our claims over the deplorable and illegal activities which took place over many years, including private investigators being hired to place secretly listening devices inside our cars and homes, the tapping of our phone calls, corrupt payments to police for inside information, and the illegal accessing of our medical information from hospitals and financial information from banks," they said in a statement issued through their lawyers.
"We intend to uncover the truth at trial and hold those responsible at Associated Newspapers fully accountable.”"
Associated Newspapers said the ruling on the confidential material was a "significant victory."
"As we have always made unequivocally clear, the lurid claims made by Prince Harry and others of phone-hacking, landline-tapping, burglary and sticky-window microphones are simply preposterous and we look forward to establishing this in court in due course," the publisher said in a statement.
The case is one of several lawsuits brought in the U.K. by Harry, who has made it a personal mission to tame Britain’s tabloid press. He blames the media for the death of his mother, Princess Diana, who was killed in a car crash in Paris in 1997 while being pursued by paparazzi.
Harry and his wife Meghan cited press intrusion as a reason for their decision to quit royal duties in 2020 and move to California.
The judge set a new hearing in the case for Nov. 21. No date has been set for the trial, where Prince Harry could give evidence. He unexpectedly attended the March hearings in the Associated Newspapers case, though he did not take the stand.
In June he became thefirst senior member of the royal family to testify in court in more than a century when he gave evidence in a separate phone hacking lawsuit against the publishers of the Daily Mirror. There hasn't yet been a ruling in that case.
Harry is also suing the publisher of The Sun newspaper alongside actor Hugh Grant. That case is scheduled to go to trial early next year.
Robert De Niro'sformer assistant awarded $1.2 million in gender discrimination lawsuit
veryGood! (576)
Related
- Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
- Massachusetts lawmakers push for drug injection sites as session wraps up
- Video tutorial: How to use Apple Maps, Google Maps to help you find a good dinner spot
- Don’t expect a balloon drop quite yet. How the virtual roll call to nominate Kamala Harris will work
- Scoot flight from Singapore to Wuhan turns back after 'technical issue' detected
- Brad Paisley invites Post Malone to perform at Grand Ole Opry: 'You and I can jam'
- Deion Sanders' son Shilo accused of trying to 'avoid responsibility' in bankruptcy case
- Michigan Supreme Court restores minimum wage and sick leave laws reversed by Republicans years ago
- Former longtime South Carolina congressman John Spratt dies at 82
- Chicago woman of viral 'green dress girl' fame sparks discourse over proper club attire
Ranking
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt's Daughter Vivienne Lands New Musical Job
- The best all-wheel drive cars to buy in 2024
- Ryan Reynolds Says He Just Learned Blake Lively's Real Last Name
- 'As foretold in the prophecy': Elon Musk and internet react as Tesla stock hits $420 all
- Why Mandy Moore Fans Think She’s Hinting at a Princess Diaries 3 Cameo
- Treat Yourself to These Luxury Beauty Products That Are Totally Worth the Splurge
- 9-month-old boy dies in backseat of hot car after parent forgets daycare drop-off
Recommendation
What were Tom Selleck's juicy final 'Blue Bloods' words in Reagan family
IHOP is bringing back its all-you-can-eat pancake deal for a limited time: Here's when
Ice Spice is equal parts coy and confident as she kicks off her first headlining tour
'Top Chef' star Shirley Chung diagnosed with stage 4 tongue cancer
Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
When Amazon sells dangerous items, it's responsible for recalling them, feds rule
2024 Olympics: Simone Biles Has the Perfect Response to Criticism Over Her Hair
Georgia prosecutors committed ‘gross negligence’ with emails in ‘Cop City’ case, judge says